Shari'ar Alex Murdaugh shine abin da ke faruwa lokacin da alkali ba su fahimci shakku mai ma'ana ba kuma alkali yana da fushi.
GARANTIN GASKIYA (References::Mujallu na ilimi: 2 kafofin] [Kai tsaye daga tushe: 2 Sources]
| By Richard Ahern - An shafe wata guda ana shari'ar kisan kai biyu na wani wulakanci lauya Alex Murdaugh - kuma na kadu da sakamakon.
Bayan sun shafe sa’o’i uku suna tattaunawa, alkalan kotun gaba daya sun same shi da laifin kashe matarsa Maggie da dansu Paul mai shekaru 22. Washegari alkali ya yi wa Mista Murdaugh hukuncin daurin rai da rai har guda biyu ba tare da yuwuwar sakin shi ba.
Kasancewa da laifin irin wannan laifin a South Carolina na iya kai ku kan hukuncin kisa; duk da haka, jihar ba ta bi hukuncin kisa ba a wannan lamarin.
Alkali mai bacin rai?
Alkalin kotun Clifton Newman bai yi tambaya kan hukuncin da jihar ta yanke ba, amma ra'ayinsa ya fito karara. Alkalin ya caccaki tsohon lauyan da aka yanke masa hukunci, inda ya ce, “A karnin da ya gabata, iyalanka, ciki har da kai, suna tuhumar mutane a nan cikin wannan dakin shari’a, kuma da yawa sun samu hukuncin kisa. Wataƙila don ƙaramin ɗabi’a.”
Alkali Newman, dan dan fafutukar kare hakkin jama'a Ishaya DeQuincey, bai ja wani naushi ba tare da dangin Murdaugh - kusan mutum zai iya cewa yana da bakin ciki. Lokacin yanke hukunci, ya ce ya cire hoton kakan Alex Murdaugh da ya rataye a bayan kotun.
Iyalin Murdaugh sun kasance sanannen suna a cikin al'ummar doka ta Lowcountry, South Carolina. Iyalin sun mallaki bangarorin biyu na dokar, mallakan babban kamfani mai zaman kansa na lauyoyi da kuma gurfanar da laifuka a jihar.
Babu shakka, Alex Murdaugh ya lalata sunan iyali kuma yana da laifuka da yawa, ciki har da sata da kuma gabatar da nasa kisan kai. An fitar da shi daga kamfanin lauyoyin danginsa lokacin da aka gano cewa ya kwashe shekaru goma yana sata daga abokan huldarsa, a wani bangare na kara rura wutar jaraba ga oxycodone (wani mai karfi mai karfi).
Murdaugh ya amince da laifukan kudi da ya aikata - amma ya ce ba zai taba cutar da matarsa da dansa ba.
An zargi Richard “Alex” Murdaugh da harbin matarsa da bindiga tare da harbin dansa da bindiga a ranar 7 ga watan Yuni 2021. Shaidar da ta daure shi da kashe-kashen abu ne mai wuyar gaske, amma ya kasance tabbataccen makaryaci kuma barawo, kuma an yi amfani da masu gabatar da kara. that masterfully against him.
Akwai ƴan takamaiman shedu akansa, babu hoton yatsu akan makaman kisan kai, kuma babu jini a hannunsa (a zahiri). Wasu shaidun ma sun karkata zuwa gare shi, kamar kusurwar wuta na sama, suna nuna cewa mai harbi yana kan guntun gefen - Mista Murdaugh yana 6'4.
Kasancewar an yi amfani da bindigu iri-iri biyu ya nuna cewa an samu harbin na biyu kuma an gano wayar Maggie Murdaugh a wani wuri daban, lamarin da ke nuni da cewa wanda ake zargin ya gudu daga wurin.
Manufar mai gabatar da kara ba ta da kyau, yana tunanin Murdaugh ya kashe matarsa da dansa don tausayawa tare da kawar da hankalin al'umma daga aikata laifukan kudi.
An kuma yi kakkausar suka ga masu binciken kan yadda suka gudanar da binciken ba daidai ba, da barin wurin da aka aikata laifin ruwan sama ya wanke, da kuma kasa tattara bayanan da suka dace na DNA.
Duk abin da ya sa na yarda cewa duk da cewa Mista Murdaugh ya kasance wanda ake tuhuma a fili - samun shi da laifi, bayan duk wani shakku mai ma'ana, ya yi kama da tsayi.
Ka tuna nauyin hujja…
Bayan wani shakku mai ma'ana ana amfani da shi ne kawai a cikin shari'o'in aikata laifuka kuma shine nauyi mafi girma, yana mai cewa wanda ake tuhuma a koyaushe ana ɗaukan wanda ba shi da laifi kuma dole ne a same shi da laifi idan babu wani bayani mai ma'ana daga shaida.
Bayan m shakka mai tushe daga Matsakaicin Blackstone, mai suna William Blackstone masanin shari’a na Ingila, wanda ya ce, “Gwamma masu laifi goma su tsere fiye da wanda marar laifi ya sha wahala.” An buga wannan a cikin 1760 kuma, har ya zuwa yau, ya zama ginshiƙin dokar aikata laifuka a duk faɗin duniya.
Benjamin Franklin Ya ci gaba da cewa: “Ya fi masu laifi ɗari su gudu da wanda marar laifi ya sha wahala.”
Dole ne masu shari'a su kasance da tabbaci game da laifi - duk da haka, a wannan yanayin, zan iya ganin wasu bayanai masu ma'ana.
Sabanin haka, a cikin shari'ar farar hula, bisa la'akari da rinjayen shaidar, wanda shine tabbas fiye da 50%, zan hukunta Mista Murdaugh a cikin bugun zuciya.
To, me ya sa aka yanke hukunci?
Da fari dai, ba za a iya musun cewa wannan wani abin kallo ne na kafofin watsa labarai tun daga farko - Netflix ya yi wani shiri game da dangi - menene kuma ya kamata a faɗi?
Nunin mai suna "Murdaugh Murders: A Southern Scandal" ya ba da labarin wani hamshakin attajiri, fitaccen lauya wanda ke cikin dangin da ke sama da doka sama da karni wanda a karshe ya samu abin da ya cancanta.
Faduwa daga alheri. Rushewar masu iko. Wanene ba ya son hakan?
Masu gabatar da kara sun goyi bayan wannan labarin, suna tunatar da alkalan shari'a game da dukiya da shaharar Alex Murdaugh da zarar ya more. Mutum ne da yake samun sama da dala miliyan daya a shekara, amma kwadayi ya sa shi yin sata daga abokan cinikinsa da suka hada da yara, nakasassu, da matattu.
Kare ya yi ta adawa da tambayar akai-akai game da laifukan kudi na Murdaugh, yana mai cewa bai dace da kisan ba. Amma kusan kowane lokaci, an buge su da "ƙin yarda" daga alkali.
An ruguza amincin Murdaugh har ya iya cewa ruwa ya jike, kuma da alkalai ba za su yarda da shi ba.
Wannan shi ne abin da ya kai shi rabin tafiya zuwa ga yanke hukunci - sauran rabin wauta ce.
Alex Murdaugh wawa ne da ya yi karya game da inda yake kafin kisan kai, sai dai wani faifan bidiyo ya bayyana yana tabbatar da cewa yana tare da Maggie da Paul mintuna kafin kisan. Ya kuma kasance wawa don kiran dansa a matsayin "Paw Paw" akan tsayawar. Oh, abin mamaki!
Alex Murdaugh ya tona sauran kabarinsa tare da shaidarsa marar gaskiya, amma bayan duk wannan, zai iya zama mutumin da ba shi da laifi saboda shaidar ba ta da tushe.
Kai tsaye daga bakin alkali:
A juri memba nan da nan ya yi magana bayan yanke hukunci, ba tare da mamaki ba ya ce dalilan da aka yanke hukuncin karya ne: game da inda yake da komai. Alkalin ya ce ya kalli wanda ake kara daidai kuma bai yarda da wani abu da ya ce ba.
“Bai yi kuka ba…. duk abin da ya yi shi ne buguwa.”—Juror wanda ya yanke wa Alex Murdaugh hukunci.
Takaita shi daidai. Amma idan an gama komai, shin mun yanke wa wani mutum hukuncin kisa wanda kawai ya yi karya (da sata)? Wataƙila ya kamata mu tambayi kanmu ko wannan wani misali ne na pendulum ɗin yana jujjuyawa da nisa.
Shin alkalai da alkali sun nuna son zuciya ga Alex Murdaugh saboda ya taba zama mai karfi?
Halin mutum ne son ganin babban mutum ya fadi; Shi ya sa labarin Dauda da Goliath ya kasance cikin tarihi, amma abin takaici ne ga dukanmu sa’ad da aka sami wani marar laifi da laifi.
Muna bukatar taimakon ku! Mun kawo muku labaran da ba a tantance ba FREE, amma za mu iya yin wannan kawai godiya ga goyon bayan masu karatu masu aminci kamar haka KA! Idan kun yi imani da 'yancin magana kuma kuna jin daɗin labarai na gaske, da fatan za a yi la'akari da tallafawa aikin mu ta zama majiɓinci ko ta hanyar yin a gudummawar lokaci ɗaya a nan. 20% na ALL ana bayar da kudade ga tsoffin sojoji!
Wannan labarin yana yiwuwa ne kawai godiya ga mu masu tallafawa da majiɓinta!
Shiga tattaunawar!